Google Signup Asking for Gmail Permission

I tried to sign up for Beeminder today just using my Google account, but it asked for permission to read all my Gmail. I said ‘cancel’ (there was no option for ‘no’) and the sign up failed. I signed up for a native beeminder account instead, but it was a little bit jarring to have that permission requested.

The Beeminder Changelog lists #439 from May 2012: Separated Gmail from Google as services you can log in with. Sorry if @bmndr was needlessly asking for permission to read your email!

So something seems to have regressed in the last six years :slight_smile:.